Liberty Mutual total loss valuation

A federal appeals court opinion describes Liberty Mutual’s total-loss valuation method as using a report on comparable vehicles provided by CCC, including condition adjustments. Here is what to check in that report — and a free check of yours in about a minute.

CCC ONE reportWhat to checkFree check in ~1 minute

Check my report free ↓

The report behind a Liberty Mutual total loss offer

In Lara v. First National Insurance Co. of America (9th Cir. 2022) the court wrote: “Liberty’s valuation method uses a report about the value of ‘comparable vehicles,’ provided by CCC.” See how a CCC ONE valuation reads.

Insurers can change vendors and report versions; the first page of the report you received names the vendor.

What to check in it

What you can ask for

Check your own report free

Upload the valuation report your insurer sent you. In about a minute you see which items may not add up — free. The full review report with a draft letter you edit and send yourself is $79.

Check my report →

Free check of your valuation report

Drop the valuation report here
PDF, or photos of every page (JPG/PNG) · up to 10 files · 25 MB

The report stays private: files are deleted within 72 hours and never used to train models. Tip: it’s the multi-page document titled “Market Valuation Report” (CCC), “Total Loss Valuation” (Mitchell) or “Autosource” (Audatex).

Your free check will appear here — usually within a minute.

Frequently asked questions

Which valuation report does Liberty Mutual use?

A 2022 federal appeals court opinion describes Liberty Mutual using CCC reports on comparable vehicles. The first page of your own report names the vendor that produced it.

Is FairTotalLoss affiliated with Liberty Mutual?

No. FairTotalLoss is independent and is not affiliated with Liberty Mutual or with CCC ONE. We read the report you upload; we never contact your insurer.

What does the free check look at?

The comparable vehicles and their adjustments, mileage, condition deductions, the base value, taxes and fees, and your vehicle details against a VIN decode.

What this is — and isn’t